Etrata – not all new art is an improvement

Last week I wrote about how my ninja deck I’m brewing was also going to have assassins, they kinda fitted together thematically.

One of the cards definitely being used was Etrata, the Silencer from Guilds of Ravnica. With the release of the Guild Packs on Friday the card got reprinted with new art.


I hate the new art, it doesn’t say assassin to me, it says dinner party. Don’t get me wrong, the art is nice. Just not as good as the original, nor evocative. For me the original art oozes vampire, assassin, creature of the night. I look at the picture and think I don’t want to meddle with them, I sure hope they aren’t after me. The new art just says to me they are waiting to be seated at a table at a restaurant.

I really don’t know what WotC thought they were doing. If I was going to commission another piece of art for this card, the brief would not allow what we have been given. I’d want it to be more visceral, showing Etrata in action maybe. Although there have been a couple of cards in the set that show similar already such as Never Happened.

I just don’t get how the new art is assassin. Sorry guys at WotC think you failed this time with the art.

Ravnica Weekend – Next Weekend

Next weekend is Ravnica Weekend at my FLGS The Hobbit Hole, and many others.

But what does this mean?

Well just over a week later, around the 20th November WotC are releasing their MtG and D&D crossover product Guildmaster’s Guide to Ravnica. So on Ravnica Weekend my FLGS is running a preview adventure from Guildmaster’s Guide to Ravnica.

Plus along side this D&D/MtG taster/preview stores can run “four-pack Booster Drafts with Guilds of Ravnica and award participants with a Ravnica foil basic land. They can also host casual Guild Kit battles with the Ravnica Guild Kits.” My FLGS is holding just the draft after the D&D/MtG taster/preview. There is also the potential for a Standard Showdown happening for those that don’t want to take part in the D&D stuff. But that’s not guaranteed. Sadly no Guild Kit battles at my FLGS, but that’s because they sold out of the stock they got in.

I’m hoping this animated GIF by WotC works. It should show the promo foil basic lands you get for taking part in the booster draft.

There are also 10 Guild prints to be used to support the drafting.


WotC through their WPN program are tracking by the looks of it the participation for both types of event for the weekend. Which I can see why. They want to know how successful this new format is, and if it’s worth doing again. It’s nice to see them try different things.

So you can see it’s a very busy weekend for MtG, more so than normal.

A big thank you to Jamey Stegmaier,

So the Stonemaier Games charity auction happened. Up for grabs by the winning bids (there were 10 lots) were the amazing looking, 4 sets of Scythe metal mechs signed by designer Jamey Stegmaier.


This blog was one of the content creators chosen to be promoted by Jamey and to nominate a charity to raise funds for.

The charity I chose was Sane.

I’d like to use this post to thank Jamey for doing this, and allowing me the opportunity to raise funds for something so personal.

If you read the blurb I wrote for the auction you will see how personal it is. This September just passed was the 30th Anniversary of my Dad committing suicide. To be able to raise money in his honour thanks to a very generous donor on bgg, Jamey and Fullfillrite is amazing. The fact I can also pay tribute to my brave friends and family who battle daily with depression and anxiety also is unbelievable.

Naturally one or two people that saw a post a few months back on a gaming Facebook forum, and close friends and family now will be crying bullshit, and my blurb also hints at it also. It’s true what I wrote above. That is the reason why I chose Sane. But and I find this part hard, because I’m not as open about this as my brave friends are. I find the really personal stuff hard to talk about. And there is still that stigma about mental health no matter what media campaigns are run. This is a “metoo”. I’m not going to go into specifics or my history, but suffice to say I am more than familiar with the struggles that my brave friends and family are going through that have depression/anxiety.

Words really can’t do justice to how I feel about Jamey having given me this opportunity to do something positive in Dad’s memory and for my friends and family. I’m overwhelmed by the generosity of the winning bid, the person who made it is incredible. A big thank you doesn’t seem adequate. But thank you.

Normal flippant, irrelevant, and boring MtG and gaming posts will resume tomorrow.

Potential Fun Combo For My Token Spamming

The Magic Historian (a YouTuber) did a change to his usual style of video about MtG and started a “community/crowd sourced” deck building project around a deck idea he had. There were a couple of rules about building the deck but that’s unimportant.

What is important is the card he said that had to be used (Island Sanctuary), the card he used to play with it back in the day (Mystic Decree) and the card he suggested people might consider (Sandwurm Convergence).

Apart from Mystic Decree (wrong colour) the other 2 cards are Selesnya colours (white and green), and would fit in nicely into my Trostani token spam deck.

I have a similar package in my Horrors from the Deep deck with Archetype of Imagination and Stormtide Leviathan.


I could see Mystic Decree being a sweet addition to that deck.

What I like about the combo of Sandwurm Convergence and Island Sanctuary is it fits in with the token spam strategy and gives me that bit of protection, breathing space to find maybe a solution to a problem on the board, develop my game plan.

It really was fortuitous coming across that video yesterday. The timing couldn’t have been better. There will be a version 2 of the Trostani deck, there are some cards in the Selesnya Guild deck that would be at home in the deck too. So there will be some reviewing going on, cards having to justify their place in the deck. But that’s also true for the Horrors of the Deep deck too. I have a handful of cards that are shouting for a place in the deck.

Winner, winner, chicken dinner II

After a weeks break I returned to my FLGS The Hobbit Hole to take part in my second ever Standard Showdown.

In between events Magic Madhouse and the Royal Mail had let me down by losing my order of a playset of Find//Finality. Everything else I ordered on the same day and after has turned up no problem. But this, a card actually important to my deck and needed, not a sign of them.

To add to my deck problems I was due to pick up a second Vivien Reid Planeswalker. But there was no one home when I called. So I was going to have to cobble together my sideboard.

Luck really was not on my side because there were no copies of Find//Finality in the store folders.

While waiting for the Standard Showdown to start, John the store owner and I took part in that age old tradition of swapping money for goods. In this case I picked up my pre-order of one each of the new Guild decks, 6 booster packs (3 Guilds of Ravnica, 1 Dominaria, 1 Shadows Over Innistrad and 1 Hour of Devestation), and I got the stores last Guild deck (Golgari). I used the really beautiful basic lands from the Golgari guild deck to replace the ones in my deck.


Todays Standard Showdown had 8 players taking part. Which meant that there would be 3 rounds of MtG.

The pairings for the first round were announced…

Round 1

The gods of pseudo random selection gave me a repeat of my opening round of my first Standard Showdown. Would history repeat itself? Would Michael once again defeat me?

Sadly for Michael my deck hit its stride and worked as intended. I hit my land drops, I used my removal to control the board state.Vivien Reid even made it out and I got to use her a couple of times.

Michael’s deck was a mono white life gain deck. That if I didn’t have as much removal as I did would have been a serious problem for me. So despite him gaining life, which was annoying, I was still able to swing in and do more damage than he was able to gain life.

I even managed to get Carnage Tyrant and Ghalta out in the games.

Final Score: Win 2-0

Round 2

This round gave me a match up that was a first for me. This was the first time I’d been opposite Ben in a tournament. Ben was playing Izzet (Blue/Red). I’d seen his deck in action against John’s Golgari deck in the previous Standard Showdown I’d attended. Then it had totally destroyed John’s deck.

Our first game was close, but in the end there wasn’t much he could do against a Carnage Tyrant and it’s mates. I think in that game I took 12 damage from Risk Factor. I wasn’t going to let Ben get that card draw and the advantage it would give him.

Our second game after some sideboarding by Ben, I think I put in an extra Ghalta and the Silent Gravestone, was a lot more comfortable a win for me.

Final Score: Win 2-0

Round 3

The final round was between Kar-Fai and myself for what was being billed by Kar-Fai the battle for top spot. Kar-Fai had been tracking wins/losses by folks, and his calculations had given him the conclusion he had reached. Me I was just shocked I’d won 2 games.

Our first game was trading blows, my Golgari hitting his I think mono red. I don’t remember a second colour. But once again I was able to control the board. I even was able to stop his Flame of Keld saga hitting it’s 3rd level with an Assassin’s Trophy.

The second game was a different story. I had to mulligan down to 5 cards to get a land! So I was already starting at a disadvantage. I did well to hang on in really for as long as I did. I was using a lot of removal to do that. Even using a Vraska’s Contempt to remove Kar-Fai’s Rekindling Phoenix. I was maybe 2 turns from being able to stand a chance of turning the game around when I lost.

The third and final game. The decider. This time Kar-Fai had to mulligan down to 5 cards. It’s not nice having to do that. I know I had to do it in the previous game. So I was feeling a little bit confident, and for the first time in the match up going first.

I think a combination of the card disadvantage, not removing my Llanowar Elf (although to be fair it would have slowed me down by a turn or two, because I had a second in hand) were too much of an advantage to over come. Not removing the Llanowar Elf meant my Steel Leaf Champion was out and doing damage. From there it was downhill for Kar-Fai. I was controlling the board, hitting him for 5 with Steel Leaf. His Flame of Keld saga went fully told, and had very little impact on the game because he had an empty battlefield, and only doubled an etb trigger so I took 4 damage that turn instead of 2.

I’d won! I’d gone 3 rounds undefeated. Wow! I was totally gobsmacked.

Final Score: Win 2-1

The WotC software did its calculations and I indeed had won this Standard Showdown. At last I’ve won when it matters! So that’s a Standard Showdown and a Prerelease I’ve won.

Winning meant I got 1 Standard Showdown pack, and 3 booster packs (1 participation pack, 2 for winning). As you can see a shiny Niv-Mizzet, and shiny swamp were in my Standard Showdown pack. I’m happy with that.


From a pure monetary value point of view I think these Standard Showdowns are good value for the entry fee of £5. Today there were 6 Standard Showdown booster packs up for grabs. So taking John out of the equation, only 1 unlucky person didn’t get one. But everyone got a participation booster. Plus 3 rounds of friendly competitive MtG. Naturally I ended up well into the black this week. But I did last time thanks to pulling an Assassin’s Trophy in my participation pack.

My playmat for the day was a recent acquisition from eBay that was a steal (With postage just under £8.)


Afterwards we played a 5 player game of Commander. I played with the Trostani token spam deck. I didn’t get any of the cards to double the tokens created. But I did flicker Trostani out a few times, and stumbled upon another tactic of the deck!

I’d put Ledev Champion in for his token generating abilities, a mana sink basically. I hadn’t really thought much of his other ability. Well until this game that is. There was that “if you gain life you lose it instead” bs enchantment out, I was accruing 1/1 soldier tokens with lifelink thanks to the flickering. But not really in my interest to attack because they were 2/2 with the +1/+1 ability of Trostani boosting them. But I could tap them to pump up Ledev Champion and swing in with a single big creature, maybe do lethal. I’ll have to look into giving him trample or making him unblockable.

I didn’t win the game of Commander. But the deck was working as planned, and I found another win condition for it. And I had fun.

What a great afternoon of MtG.

So for the one or two out there remotely interested in the tweaks I’ve made to the deck for this week, here I present my deck list for this second Standard Showdown.

The big change was putting Ritual of Soot in the main 60. Space for them was made by moving Mastermind’s Acquisition to the sideboard. I’ve also found space in the main 60 for Vivien Reid to start.

In the deck list below I’ve put the cards in bold that will get replaced once I get copies of Find//Finality. I’m going to have to think long and hard how the second copy of Vivien Reid fits in.

Creatures:26

4 Llanowar Elves
2 Skittering Heartstopper
4 Vicious Conquistador
3 Dire Fleet Poisoner
4 Steel Leaf Champion
2 Thrashing Brontodon
1 Nullhide Ferox
3 Ravenous Chupacabra
2 Carnage Tyrant
1 Ghalta, Primal Hunger

Spells:13

4 Assassin’s Trophy
2 Never Happened
2 Ritual of Soot
4 Vraska’s Contempt
1 Vivien Reid

Lands:21

6 Forest
1 Foul Orchard
4 Golgari Guildgate (a)
1 Overgrown Tomb
7 Swamp
2 Woodland Cemetery

Sideboard:15

2 Skittering Heartstopper
1 Dire Fleet Poisoner
2 Kitesail Freebooter
2 Thrashing Brontodon
1 Demon of Catastrophes
1 Doom Whisperer
1 Ghalta, Primal Hunger
1 Silent Gravestone
1 Status // Statue
2 Mastermind’s Acquisition

1 Vraska, Golgari Queen

Drafting Dream Eater

Dream Eater from Guilds of Ravnica…
I kinda like the card. I can see it fitting into my Muldrotha Commander deck. That deck wants cards in the graveyard, and surveil was built for that deck. So being able to look at 4 cards, arrange them in any order and put back on top of the library, or put them into the graveyard is huge.

For 6 CMC there seems to be a lot of value when casting it. Firstly it has Flash, so you get to play it like an instant.

It’s a flying 4/3, which isn’t too shabby. But the card can be taken out by single hit removal like a lightning bolt. Which kinda is a negative.

Finally there is the surveil 4 that I’ve already talked about. Which to me is it’s big advantage. Flash out on the end step before your turn, allows you to make sure you are hopefully drawing the right card for the turn and putting useful stuff in the graveyard.

Not sure yet which card will get replaced by Dream Eater in the Muldrotha deck. But I do have a couple of “upgrades” I’m thinking about adding to the deck. So I can look at them at the same time I’m evaluating cards against Dream Eater. A deck is never finished…

Jack is nowhere near this beanstalk

Once again I seem to have been sleeping and missed this announcement at the start of October.
Since I sold up and stopped playing Netrunner I’ve missed the game and the Android universe. I really do love the whole cyberpunk, Bladerunner-esq setting. It’s a genre I love. And the art that has been created for the Android universe (read Netrunner) is some of my all time favourite. It’s just stunning, atmospheric, and thematic. Look at the art above for the cover of the book. It screams Bladerunner, and already you have that whole neon, gritty, industrial, futuristic world in your imagination as the setting. Gorgeous. Anyone that’s seen one of the movies or the many ones after that it’s influenced will be instantly at home and have frames of reference they can start using to imagine their adventures in the Android universe.

Which is why when they released the Genesys RPG system and covered a cyberpunk setting within it I was excited. It was obvious from the art used that they were implying an Android type setting. After the release they talked about the world of Android being one of the source books they would be working on.


Now that FFG have gotten their fantasy themed sourcebook out in the world, their attention has turned to Android. You can now pre-order Android: Shadow of the Beanstalk, the sourcebook for the Genesys system covering the Android universe. Although sadly there is no actual release date yet. So I’m hoping that pre-order means soon.

You can read the full post about it from FFG here.

P.S. FFG can we have the Tannhäuser universe next please?

Ninjas meet Assassins

One of my planned Commander deck ideas is a ninja themed deck with Yuriko, the Tiger’s Shadow from Commander 2018 as it’s Commander.

I think it’s accepted that there are not enough (good) ninjas to make a deck with. Which has been a bit of a brake on the brewing of the deck.

But then I had a moment of clarity when I saw the card Etrata, the Silencer.


Assassins are like ninjas! How about if I make the deck a ninjas and assassins deck?

Thematically it works. Or it does in my little make believe world.

It means I can’t use tribal boosters, or if I do it will be to boost a subset of the creature base. Unless I run Arcane Adaptation to make them all one creature type. The half way solution could be to run a mix of general boosts and tribal ones.

But that’s the updated plan for the ninja deck, or ninjas and assassins deck. What assassins should I put in the deck?

City building


If you had seen Jonathan, Diego and myself get all excited when the young lady behind the counter/bar at The Luxe poured Diego his Guinness, the first words you would have thought of were “Sad gits”. Or words to that effect. You might have put the odd more colourful word in for example.

But it doesn’t get away from the marvellous bit of science going on. I’ve managed to find the official video of what I’ve just found out is called the Guinness Surge.

I’ve had Suburbia in my collection for a couple of years now, and never managed to get it to the table. That is until Saturday afternoon, when at long last I did finally get the game to the table.

I enjoyed the game, despite coming first loser. I think Diego enjoyed the experience of playing to a very convincing victory. However Jonathan had a bit of a mare of a game.

My part of the city had a pretty effective money creating engine going. But there was a period mid game where I was not going up on the population track because my reputation was zero. I did hit a negative value for a turn, but I managed to get a tile to negate it and take me to zero. It slowed me down, and after that there was no real catching Diego up.

However Jonathan fell into a similar trap in the later third of the game but with income that meant he found it very hard to do anything apart from cover the money he would lose at the end of each round. It was almost a negative loop feeding into itself. It really did ruin the experience of the game for him. There was also some misunderstanding on how tiles worked, and one or two tiles and their wording.

It was a learning game. Mistakes were bound to be made. It’s a shame that the experience wasn’t pleasurable for John.

I liked the game. It’s definitely a game I’d like to get to the table again.

After building our city districts we wound down with a game or two of Perudo. We were using the 30th Anniversary Liars Dice instead of my Perudo set. But the rules we used we a mish mash of the 2 games. We used the bidding of Liars Dice, and thus the playmat that comes with the 30th Anniversary Edition to track the bids. But the rules from Perudo for everything else.

I love the components, especially the playmat of the Anniversary edition. But it is so let down by the awful, cheap, box it comes in. Why make all the fuss about it being this 30th Anniversary Edition and then cheap out on the box it comes in?

If you are remotely interested in the outcome of the games you can look on bgg here.

Our final game was a few plays of No Thanks! I don’t think Gavin realised the monster he unleashed when he introduced the game to us at the last Monthly meetup. We’ve now introduced it to two more people. I think so we don’t burn out on the game, we will have to switch back to say Red7 or some other quick, light filler game we can end the evening with. Although Perudo has also filled that spot on occasion.

I’m beginning to sound like a broken record, but a big big thank you to The Luxe for once again allowing us to use their premises for our gaming. And yet again another fantastic afternoon gaming with 2 of the best people to game with.

Asmodee UK Website Fail

It’s been like this for most of today. It was like it for a large part of yesterday.


You would have thought with Essen on at the moment, you’d want your site up and running. Friday is meant to be the day Asmodee UK share with the world, well UK the new releases for the week ahead. It’s definitely where a lot of gamers go to see what they will be spending money on.

Plus with the worlds largest board gaming expo currently in progress you’d want your site sharing tweets, news etc to your customer base that are unable to get there.

I’m not expecting the situation to improve before Monday. Maybe they might have a decision maker who can authorise money to be spent back by then.

Until then I can’t see their IT bods able to do anything about this.

Embarrassed much?